Phone Icon (508) 548-2500 — Falmouth Office
(508) 477-0021 — Mashpee Office

request a quote

Facebook Icon

Protecting Your Assets With Customized Coverage

Independent Insurance Agency in Falmouth, MA

Keeping your property safe shouldn't be a chore. At Paul Peters Agency, Inc., we offer a wide variety of insurance policies for drivers, homeowners, and business owners. Staffed by a team of incredibly experienced agents, our company strives to demystify the world of insurance and help you find coverage that truly works for you.

House Icon

Homeowner's Insurance

Car Icon

Auto & Umbrella Policies

Business Building Icon

Business Insurance

Rely on the oldest insurance agency in the area for the coverage you need.

(508) 548-2500 — Falmouth Office
(508) 477-0021 — Mashpee Office

About Us

Paul Peters Insurance Agency is the oldest active insurance agency in Falmouth, Massachusetts. Our team of dedicated agents has provided insurance services to our neighbors since 1930. Today, we draw on that immense experience to guarantee the best possible coverage for our customers.

As an independent agency, we work for you, not an insurance company. We stay by your side when you're facing a loss and follow through to make sure you get a fair settlement on all of your insurance claims. Our independence allows us to quote premiums from many different companies, finding you the best services and prices for your specific needs.

Over the years, we have gained the expertise to match the right person to the right insurance company. This is our strength. Through our complete evaluation, we take note of your requirements and find a total insurance solution just for you.

View Our Staff & Carriers

Building Exterior


Thank you for your interest. We look forward to hearing from you soon.

(508) 548-2500 — Falmouth Office
(508) 540-9641 — Falmouth Fax
(508) 477-0021 — Mashpee Office
(508) 477-6498 — Mashpee Fax

Falmouth Office:
6 Falmouth Heights Road
Falmouth, MA 02540

Falmouth Mailing Address:
P.O. Box 669
Falmouth, MA 02541

Serving Cape Cod, MA

Mashpee Office:
680 Falmouth Road
Mashpee, MA 02649

Mashpee Mailing Address:
P.O. Box 1290
Mashpee, MA 02649

View Locations

Hours of Operation
Monday – Friday: 8:30 a.m. – 4:30 p.m.

Facebook Icon

Request a Quote